The maulvi states that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) has stated in Ruhani Khazain that sahaba had an ijma that Isa(as) had passed away but in other sayings he says that the death of Jesus(as) is something that no one from before me knew rather Allah has opened this secret to me. He tries to state that this is a clear contradiction but in reality he has failed with this allegation as I will answer.
The maulvi has once again lied and took things out of context and did not even read what Ahmad(as) has said. He made his own saying. Never did Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) say this. This is another challenge to show us such a statement but never will you find such a statement that no one had knowledge of it.
Let us see in reality what Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) has written:
In reality when we read the passage Ahmad(as) has said that the Qur’an, Hadith Nabawi and the salaf prove that Isa(As) has died rather than him(as) writing that no one had the view of the death of Isa(as) before him. Ahmad(as) has numbered them as you can see from the passage. Next the maulvi quotes this passage:
On this exact page it says that the Qur’an has already proven that Isa(as) has died. It starts from the page I quoted before this one where Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) has clearly quoted the Qur’an, then the ahadith, and then the salaf as well which includes the sahaba and Muhammad(saw). This topic being spoken about above is in regards to the nazul-e-masih rather than the death of Isa(as) which is another lie that the maulvi has stated. The maulvi has said his own words nothing he said was stated in the works of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as).
Now let us go to the second part of which he states in regards to Ruhani Khazain that no one before the promised Messiah(as) knew about this. This is once again another lie of the maulvi. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) states:
No where does it state that the death of Isa(as) was not known to anywhere before the Promised Messiah(as), rather in this book itself Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) has named people who before him had this belief repeatedly. In fact if we just go four pages ahead Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) has stated:
He basically quotes majmaul Bahar and Tabarani and quoted that Ayesha(ra) and Imam Malik(ra) both had the belief of death of Isa(as), The maulvi has clearly lied about this as well and stated that the Promised Messiah(as) said that no one was aware of this belief.
Now let us look at the statement which the maulvi has twisted. The Promised Messiah(as) has basically stated that Allah has made him the mujadid and has told him that the Messiah(as) has indeed died and that the one the Muslims and Christians are waiting for are indeed you. Ahmad(as) was told by Allah that he is that messiah and that not to be of the ones who doubt. Ahmad(as) than states that he was one of those who Allah has told about the belief of death of Isa(as). Never did he say that no one before him had this belief. Ahmad(as) has showed the death of Jesus not just from the Qur’an but the bible as well, and even gave his entire journey. Nowadays a lot of Muslims have the belief that Isa(as) has indeed died because the Qur’an is clear on his death.