Contact
AhmadiAnswers | False tafsir Tanwir Al Miqbas
17347
page-template,page-template-full_width,page-template-full_width-php,page,page-id-17347,page-child,parent-pageid-17129,do-etfw,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,side_area_uncovered_from_content,qode-theme-ver-9.1.3,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-4.11.2.1,vc_responsive
 

False tafsir Tanwir Al Miqbas

False tafsir Tanwir Al Miqbas

This is a totally daif tafseer and here and many references from non Ahmadi scholars themselves.

 

ome quotes of people regarding it:

1) Muhammad bin Marwaan Siddi Al-Koofi. He is popularly known as Siddi as-Sagheer

 

Imam Dhahabi said about him: Muhadditheen have abandoned him and he is accused of lying by some and he is a student of Kalbi. (Meezan-ul-I’tidaal 4/32).

 

Imam Bukhari said: He is Matrook (Taarikh Al-Kabeer 1/232,Narrations can never be written from him (Ad-Dua’fa as-Sagheer p-350)

 

Imam Nasa’ee said: He is abandoned in hadith (Ad-Dua’fa wal Matrookeen 538)

 

Imam Bayhaqi said: He is matrook (Kitaab Asma-wa-Sifaat p-94)

 

Imam Yahya bin Maeen said: He is not thiqah (Al-Jarh wa tadeel 8/86)

 

Imam Abu Haatim ar-Razee said: Matrook (Al-Jarh wa tadeel 8/86)

 

Imam Ibn Hibban said: He used to narrate fabricated narrations from Thiqah narrators. Its not permissible to write from him (Al-Majrooheen 2/286)

 

Imam Ibn Numayr said: Kadhab (liar) (Ad-Dua’fa al-Kabeer of Uqaili 4/136)

 

Hafidh Ibn Hajr said: Accused of lying (Taqreeb at-tahzeeb 6284)

 

Hafidh Haythami said: He is weak by Ijmaa. (Majoo az-Zawaaid 1/214)

 

2) Muhammad bin Saa’ib Kalbi

 

Imam Abu Haatim Ar-Razee said: There is an Ijmaa of people that his ahadith are Matrook.
(Al-Jarh wa tadeel 7/271)

 

Imam Sulaymaan At-Taymee said: There were two Kadhaab (liars) in Kufaa and one among them was Kalbi.(Al-Jarh wa tadeel 7/270)

 

Imam Jawzjani said: Kadhab (liar) (Ahwaal-ar-Rijaal 37)

 

Hafidh Ibn Hajr said: Accused of Kadhb and Rafd (Taqreeb at-Tahzeeb 5901)

 

3) Bazaam Abu Saleh

 

Imam Nasa’ee said: Daeef Koofi. (Ad-Duaafa wal-Matrookeen 72)

 

Imam Bukhari mentioned him in (Kitaab at-Dua’afa :21)

 

Imam Dhahabi said: Daeeful-hadith (Deewan ad-dua’fa 544)

 

Hafidh Ibn Hajr said: Daeef (Taqreeb at-Tahzeeb 634)

 

These include imam Bukhari(ra), Imam Dhahabi(ra) and Ibn Hajr Asqalani(Ra)so be careful when quoting such tafsir.