The allegation of the non Ahmadi Muslims is that verses of the Qur’an were revealed to Ahmadas and that this is not Islamic. This is a baseless allegation and shows the ignorance of these so called scholars.
Firstly, the ones who believe Isaas is alive and that he will descend to spread the message of Islam, are forced to also believe that he would be given knowledge about Islam from Allah through revelation. Now if that Messiah was to descend, it would be a must for Allah to teach him the entire Qur’an through revelation or else how would he be able to spread the teachings of Islam? If Allah would not reveal it to him, who would he learn from? Deobandis or Barelwis? Ahle Hadith or Wahabis? No matter who teaches him, the opposing sects will declare him to be a disbeliever and claim that he is only a messiah of their sect and not ours. Now if they are forced to believe that Allah would reveal the entire Qur’an if Jesus sent to Bani Israel would return, why raise an objejction against a couple of verses revealed to Ahmadas?
Furthermore, the scholars of the non Ahmadi Muslims themselves who are well respected saints were also revealed Quranic verses. Do the non Ahmadi Muslims dare to call them liars as well?
Khawaja Mir Dard of Delhi has stated that he was revealed verses of the Qur’an in his book Il Al Kitab under Tahdees Ni’mat ar Rabb:
“Warn thy near relatives.” (The Quran, 26:215)
“Say: Allah is sufficient for me.” (39:39)
“Be steadfast as thou art commanded, and follow not their low desires.” (42:16)
“Grieve thou not for them, nor be distressed because of what they plan.” (27:71)
“Did He not find thee groping, and guided thee.” (93:8) ( ‘Ilm al-Kitab, pp. 61 – 64.)
Maulvi Abdullah Ghaznavi who was another Indian Saint near the time of Ahmadas stated that he received verses as well:
“Send peace and blessings upon him.” (The Quran 33:57)
“And soon thy Lord will give thee so that thou art well pleased.” (93:6)
“Have We not expanded for thee thy bosom.” (94:2)
“Is not God sufficient for His servant.” (39:37)
“He is only a servant upon whom We bestowed favours.” (43:60)
He also received the following revelation
“Thou art from Me and I am from Thee. So fear not nor grieve.” (Biography of Maulavi Abdullah Ghaznavi by Maulavi Abdul Jabbar Ghaznavi, pp. 10 – 11)
Hazrat Sayyid Abdul Qadir Jilanirh has stated: “Woe unto you, O innovator! Does God not have the power to say: I am God. Our God, great is His glory, is a speaker, and not dumb. His word is heard and understood.”(Al-Fath ar-Rabbani, p. 153)
He also states:“When you attain perfection in fana [annihilation], your rank near God will be raised, and you will be addressed in the words: This day you are with us, a dignified, trusted one.”(Futuh al-Ghaib, with Persian commentary, Discourse no. 28, p. 171) (Referring to Chapter 12 Verse 55)
He further states: The words wa-stana‘tu-ka li-nafsi (I have chosen thee especially for Myself), which are in the Quranic verse 20:41, were revealed to Abdul Qadir Jilani several times. (ibid., p. 33)
It is also an allegation that “In a Misconception Removed” Ahmadas states:
“In the same book, close upon the above Divine Communication, is this Divine revelation:
مُحَمَّدٌ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ ۚ وَالَّذِينَ مَعَهُ أَشِدَّاءُ عَلَى الْكُفَّارِ رُحَمَاءُ بَيْنَهُمْ ۖ
“Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, and those who are with him are hard against the disbelievers, tender amongst themselves. (Chapter 48 Verse 30)
In which I have been named ‘Muhammad’ as well as ‘Mesenger’.” (A Misconception Removed Page 2)
There is nothing wrong with Qur’an being revealed on a person, rather it shows their truthfulness. When we go to Tazkiratul Auliya it states a saying of Hazrat Abu al Hasan Kharqanirh who is widely respected as a pious Muslim Saint:
“I am God of this age. I am Mustafa of this age” (Tadhkiratul Auliya, page 585)
Furthermore, Hazrat Abu Yazid Bustamirh stated when asked by someone:
‘What is ‘arsh. He said, I am that. He asked, what is Kursi. He replied, I am that. People said that there have been many righteous servants of God such as Abraham, Moses and the Holy Prophet. He said, I am all of them. They, then, asked about the angels Gabriel, Michael, Israfeel and Izraeel. He said, I am all of them as well.’”(Tadhkiratul Aulia Chapter 14 page 146)
This is another sign of the truthfulness of Ahmadas for the non Ahmadi Muslims who follow saints that had similar revelations. Either they should accept both recipients of revelation or reject both. It is obvious that they will have to accept both if they are truthful.